‘Fiddler' a musical theater tradition worth revisiting - Omaha.com
go logo
article photo
article photo
John Preece puts his own stamp on the character Tevye.


‘Fiddler' a musical theater tradition worth revisiting
By Todd von Kampen

He may still be a few hundred performances shy of his character's most prolific performer, but it's delightfully obvious that John Preece knows Tevye the milkman as intimately as Tevye knows his God.

Only a few scattered seats were empty Tuesday night at the Orpheum Theater, where Preece, who last headlined “Fiddler on the Roof” in Omaha in 2005, opened a six-day run in the midst of his 10th national tour in the immortal Broadway musical.

Ably backed by an outstanding cast, Preece puts his own definitive stamp on one of the musical theater's most beloved roles — though one can clearly perceive his respect for Zero Mostel, Broadway's original Tevye, as well as Topol, who originated the role on the London stage and set the role's permanent standard in the 1971 movie.

When he finally retired from the role in 2009, Topol had some 2,500 performances as Tevye to his credit. Preece, with nearly 1,800 appearances of his own, separates himself from the Israeli-born actor with a slightly more humorous approach to the script's funniest lines and a softer, less restrained depiction of Tevye's emotions as the outside world invades and finally conquers his corner of 1905 Russia.

As Tevye explains the purpose of the Jewish prayer shawl early in “Tradition,” Preece drew laughter with a pregnant pause before answering, “How did this tradition get started?” with “I don't know.” But when third daughter Chava (Chelsey LeBel) declares her intention to marry the Christian Fyedka (Michael Shultz), Preece objects with a desperate anguish that remains consistent whenever her choice confronts him.

The other leading cast members likewise approach their roles with the confidence to avoid spot-on imitations of their predecessors on film. Andrew Boza, for example, takes Motel the tailor to new levels of geekiness as he initially shrinks from asking Tevye's permission to marry Tzeitel (Brooke Hills). But that merely heightens the moment when Motel forcefully discovers his own maturity: “Even a poor tailor is entitled to some happiness!”

Joshua Phan-Gruber's performance as Perchik, meanwhile, offers a reminder of the shortcomings of even the best Broadway film adaptations. He sings “Now I Have Everything,” omitted from the movie, in a way that proves that Perchik isn't completely clueless in expressing his feelings for Hodel (Sarah Sesler). The movie also eliminated a second-act speech more clearly linking Perchik's student activism to the spreading anti-Semitism in late czarist Russia.

Gerri Weagraff's Golde seems a bit less the shrew than small-screen audiences may be used to. But her character's Type A qualities had the audience roaring as she tries to get Tevye to meet Lazar Wolf (David B. Springstead Sr.) for the latter's proposal to Tzeitel. “Will you talk to him?” she says surprisingly sweetly before immediately letting Tevye have it: “WILL YOU TALK TO HIM?”

The vocal performances will disappoint few who attend “Fiddler” this week, though the chorus' staccato delivery of “Anatevka” eroded the song's mournful quality. As the show opens, however, the cast delivers “Tradition” with a powerful punch and crystal-clear diction that immediately captures the audience's attention.

Director Sammy Dallas Bayes reproduces Broadway legend Jerome Robbins' original choreography in this touring version.

How well does the cast perform the famous “bottle dance” at Tzeitel and Motel's wedding? The roar from the audience at its climax told it all. Spend a night in Anatevka this week if you can.

Contact the Omaha World-Herald newsroom

Copyright ©2014 Omaha World-Herald®. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, displayed or redistributed for any purpose without permission from the Omaha World-Herald.

Latest Stories

Omaha's dive-iest dive bars
Omaha's dive-iest dive bars

Omaha's many neighborhood bars run the gamut of experiences.

Dining notes: Famous Dave’s moving to new spot
Dining notes: Famous Dave’s moving to new spot

Council Bluffs’ Famous Dave’s is relocating.

South Omaha will celebrate Cinco de Mayo with Mexican food fest
South Omaha will celebrate Cinco de Mayo with Mexican food fest

This year, for the first time, South Omaha will celebrate Cinco de Mayo with an authentic Mexican food festival.

Sawyer Brown known for its 'Nebraska Song'

Sawyer Brown is known for its three No. 1 country hits and 16 studio albums, but here in Nebraska, it's mostly known for one thing.

Why is ketchup so hard to pour?
Why is ketchup so hard to pour?

Why is ketchup so hard to pour? It has to do the fact that it’s a strange kind of fluid that behaves like a solid. Sometimes.

Opera Omaha's 'Cinderella' is a little different, but story is still universal
Opera Omaha's 'Cinderella' is a little different, but story is still universal

Joan Font always knew “Cinderella” was a universal story. He just didn't realize how universal it was.

Live Music Calendar

A roundup of live music events in the Omaha area.

Big weekend ahead for Nebraska Wind Symphony

During a concert Sunday, the Nebraska Wind Symphony will induct two members into its hall of fame, celebrate the 35th anniversary of the Music in Catholic Schools, present a concerto by the winner of its annual memorial scholarship and feature a sixth-grader as a guest conductor.

Theater events listing

A list of opening and upcoming theater events.

Black Lips show staying power
Black Lips show staying power

With seven albums, the band has managed to stick around far longer than its influences.

Movies Opening this week

Movie showtimes and theater listings

Read this!


Tonight in Prime Time
© 2014 Omaha World-Herald. All rights reserved